What Happens if You Lose a Chargeback?

Chargebacks are a headache no merchant wants, yet they're an all-too-common part of doing business. You put in the effort to prevent them, meticulously tracking transactions and providing excellent customer service, but sometimes a dispute slips through the cracks and you're left facing the possibility of a loss.

But what happens if you lose a chargeback exactly? Sure, you lose the income you earned from the sale, the cost of goods sold, the cost of fulfillment, and potentially even a bit of cash from chargeback fees.

However, there is more to the story.

Losing a chargeback can also escalate to higher merchant fees, a tarnished reputation, and an increased risk of losing your card processing privileges.

But it's not all doom and gloom. We're here to guide you through the aftermath of a lost chargeback and, more importantly, to share proven tactics to help you win more disputes and prevent them from happening in the first place. 

The best way? Investing in Disputifier. Our chargeback company helps you retain the revenue you’ve earned by preventing chargebacks and fighting them on your behalf should disputes arise. It’s all automated, and you don’t have to lift a finger - you only pay when we win, too! 

Overview of the Chargeback Process

In order to understand what happens if you lose a chargeback, we need to take a step back and look at the entire process from start to finish. 

A chargeback occurs when a customer disputes a transaction with their card issuer. It's a form of consumer protection that can be initiated for various reasons, such as unauthorized use of the card, issues with the product or service, or transaction errors. Here's how it typically unfolds:

  1. Dispute Initiation: The customer spots a transaction they don't recognize or disagree with and contacts their bank to dispute the charge. Or, perhaps it’s outright fraud, and the “customer” is simply trying to get one over on an innocent business. Whatever the case, the bank steps in from there.
  2. Bank Investigation: The issuing bank reviews the claim to determine its validity and, if it appears justified, provisionally credits the customer's account, then files a chargeback on the customer's behalf.
  3. Merchant Notification: The merchant is alerted about the chargeback and provided with details, including the reason code which indicates the nature of the dispute.
  4. Merchant Response: The merchant has the opportunity to accept the chargeback or fight it by providing evidence that the transaction was legitimate.
  5. Evidence Review: The issuing bank, and sometimes the card network, reviews the evidence submitted. If the merchant's evidence is compelling, the chargeback may be overturned.
  6. Final Decision: If the merchant's evidence is not convincing, or if they choose not to contest the chargeback, the provisional credit to the customer becomes permanent, and the merchant loses the funds from the transaction.

Each step in this process involves strict deadlines and detailed requirements for documentation on the merchant’s behalf in order to win. 

But, the average chargeback win rate is fairly low for merchants at just 20-40% depending on the level of risk associated with your business. While Disputifier can boost this to as high as 70%, it’s still worth knowing what happens if you lose a chargeback.

What Happens if You Lose a Chargeback?

When a merchant loses a chargeback, the immediate consequence is the loss of both the disputed funds and the product or service already delivered. 

This double-edged sword cuts into profits and can disrupt cash flow, particularly for small businesses or those with tight margins. But like we said from the start, the lost capital is just the tip of the iceberg. 

Direct Financial Losses Explained

The financial impact of a lost chargeback extends beyond the transaction amount. Merchants are also responsible for covering the chargeback fee imposed by their payment processor, which can range from $20 to $100 per incident. This administrative fee is typically non-refundable, regardless of the dispute's outcome.

Additional Costs: Fees, Time, and Resources

The time and labor invested in compiling evidence, communicating with banks, and disputing the chargeback divert resources from other business areas. For many merchants, this means hours spent on chargeback resolution instead of growth and customer service initiatives. 

Moreover, payment processors may increase transaction fees or require a reserve fund to be established if a merchant experiences high chargeback rates. This ties up capital that could be used elsewhere in the business and cuts into your margins.

In extreme cases, merchants may find themselves seeking new payment processors if their current provider decides the risk level is too high, leading to potential disruptions in service and additional setup fees.

Long-Term Repercussions on Business Operations

A high chargeback ratio can damage relationships with payment processors and card networks, leading to a merchant being placed in high-risk processing categories or, in severe cases, losing their merchant account entirely. 

This can significantly hinder a business's ability to operate, as the ability to process card payments is essential for modern commerce.

Additionally, frequent chargebacks can tarnish a merchant's reputation with customers and within the industry. Customers who win chargebacks may share their experiences, potentially influencing others and deterring future business. This reputational damage can be difficult to quantify but is no less real in its impact on a merchant's long-term success.

Now What?

So, if you’ve lost a chargeback, is this just the final verdict for you? Not necessarily. It’s important to understand that there's another layer to the process known as pre-arbitration, or the second chargeback. 

This is essentially a second chance for merchants to present their case before the issue potentially escalates to arbitration with the card networks. Here’s how you can use it to overturn the initial verdict…

The Process of Pre-Arbitration Explained

Pre-arbitration comes into play when a merchant disagrees with the outcome of the initial chargeback. In other words, when you lose.

In this phase, the merchant can present new evidence or reiterate their position with additional details that may not have been considered previously. It allows for the dispute to be reviewed anew, potentially overturning the initial decision.

After receiving notification of a lost chargeback, a merchant has a limited window to respond if they choose to pursue pre-arbitration. The process involves:

  1. Gathering additional compelling evidence that counters the reason for the chargeback.
  2. Submitting a detailed rebuttal that addresses the points of contention.
  3. Ensuring all documentation adheres to the requirements set by the payment processor and card networks.

Potential Outcomes

If your pre-arbitration case is strong, the issuing bank may reverse the chargeback, restoring the funds to the merchant. However, if the bank upholds its decision, the case may move to arbitration, where the card network makes a final ruling. 

It's important to note that arbitration can be costly, and the losing party is often responsible for the fees associated with this process. This underscores the importance of a strong rebuttal.

A robust and well-documented rebuttal during pre-arbitration can make the difference between recovering funds or absorbing the loss. It's a merchant's opportunity to clarify misunderstandings or provide context that wasn't considered initially. 

This step is not to be taken lightly, as it may be the last chance to avoid the additional costs and complexities of arbitration. So - don’t give up hope if you lose a chargeback. There is more you can do to turn the ruling back in your favor through pre-arbitration. But ultimately, your best bet as a merchant is to take steps to avoid losing chargebacks in the first place.

Tips to Avoid Losing Chargebacks in the First Place

With an awareness of what happens if you lose a chargeback, it’s obviously worth investing time and resources into preventing chargebacks and fighting them when they inevitably pop up. 

So, here are some tips to 1) lower your chances of chargeback occurrence and 2) increase your dispute win rage.

Implementing Strong Customer Service Policies

Exceptional customer service is your first line of defense against chargebacks. A transparent and accessible approach can often resolve issues before they escalate into disputes. 

Ensure that your customer service team is well-trained, responsive, and empowered to address customer concerns quickly and effectively. Offering multiple channels of support, such as phone, email, and live chat, can improve accessibility and customer satisfaction.

Many issues associated with “order not delivered” disputes come down to poor communication. So, keep your customers informed throughout the purchasing process, from transaction confirmation to shipping updates. 

If a customer does contact you with a problem, listen actively to their concerns, and offer fair solutions. Sometimes, issuing a refund is more cost-effective than dealing with a chargeback, both in direct costs and in preserving customer relationships.

Utilizing Fraud Detection Tools and Services

Fraudulent transactions are the most common cause of chargebacks. Implementing advanced fraud detection tools can help identify and prevent suspicious activity before it results in a chargeback. 

Many payment processors offer services that filter transactions based on data points like IP address, geolocation, and unusual spending patterns.

Consider using services that require card verification values (CVVs) and employ 3D Secure technology, which adds an additional layer of authentication for online transactions. 

Address Verification Service (AVS) is another tool that compares the billing address provided by the customer with the one on file with the card issuer, flagging discrepancies for further review.

Stay informed about the latest fraud trends and ensure your fraud prevention measures evolve to keep pace with sophisticated tactics. Regularly reviewing transactions for signs of fraud can help catch issues early and reduce the risk of chargebacks due to unauthorized card use.

Creating Clear Payment Descriptors and Return Policies

Confusion over a charge on a statement is a common reason for chargebacks. Use clear and recognizable billing descriptors to avoid this. 

Your descriptor should include your business name and contact information, making it easy for customers to recall their purchase and reach out to you directly with any concerns.

Clear, concise, and customer-friendly return policies can also deter chargebacks. Make sure your policy is easy to find and understand, ideally displayed on your website and included in purchase confirmations. Set reasonable expectations for returns and refunds, and stick to them.

Stop Worrying About What Happens if You Lose a Chargeback - Enjoy Peace of Mind With Disputifier!

Investing in the best chargeback companies that prevent and fight disputes on your behalf is like investing in peace of mind. You never have to even think about chargebacks again. 

Of all the options you have at your disposal, Disputifier is the #1 choice. We’re trusted by your favorite brands - like Doe, Tabs, Ryze, and hundreds of others.

Our platform leverages cutting-edge AI technology to scrutinize every transaction, identifying potential fraud before it culminates in a chargeback. Disputifier's sophisticated algorithms analyze patterns and flag high-risk transactions in real-time, significantly reducing the likelihood of fraudulent charges. 

We've partnered with leading services like Verifi™ and Ethoca™ to offer real-time chargeback alerts. This collaboration enables us to notify you the instant a chargeback is initiated, giving you the maximum amount of time to respond and resolve the issue directly with the customer.

We also offer tools to mitigate instances of “order not received”. Our system ensures that customers are well informed about the status of their orders, reducing confusion and the impulse to file a chargeback. 

Should any delivery issues arise, our proactive communication helps resolve them swiftly, often before the customer feels compelled to contact their bank. 

All of these tactics keep 99% of chargebacks from ever occurring in the first place. But in the event that one does slip through the cracks, we’re there to help you fight it head-on - without you having to do any of the heavy lifting.  

Disputifier's automated recovery system crafts and submits customized, compelling dispute responses on your behalf. We fight thousands of chargebacks every month, continuously refining our strategies through split testing to ensure the highest possible win rate for your disputes. In fact, our customers see win rates up to 67%!

You can request a demo today to learn more about how our solution works. Or better yet, get started for free with a risk-free trial. You only pay when you win!

Closing Thoughts on What Happens if You Lose a Chargeback

Losing a chargeback can be a costly and frustrating experience, impacting your revenue, resources, and reputation. Now that you know what happens if you lose a chargeback, we hope you feel compelled to take action and protect yourself and your business from disputes going forward.

Proactive prevention, swift detection, and strategic dispute management to mitigate the risks and repercussions of chargebacks will pay off in the long run. Plus, Disputifier can automate most of this for you - so all you have to do is get set up and let us do all the hard work.

Embrace the tranquility that comes with having Disputifier on your side - try our solution today, and let us transform chargeback turmoil into a concern of the past.

How to Protect Against Chargebacks for Item Not as Described

How Do Chargebacks Affect a Business

You May Also Like