Running an eCommerce store on Shopify offers incredible opportunities but also unique challenges. One of the most pressing issues is dealing with high-risk orders, which can lead to chargebacks, lost revenue, and potential damage to your business's reputation. 

But what exactly are high-risk orders, and how can merchants identify and handle them effectively?

‍

What Are High-Risk Orders?

High-risk orders refer to transactions flagged as potentially fraudulent or likely to result in chargebacks. These orders may involve stolen credit card details, unauthorized transactions, or instances of "friendly fraud," where customers dispute charges for valid purchases. 

Shopify uses advanced algorithms to categorize orders as low, medium, or high risk based on several factors, including mismatched billing and shipping addresses, unusual purchasing patterns, or multiple failed payment attempts.

For merchants, high-risk orders represent significant financial exposure. Beyond losing the value of the sale, merchants can face additional costs, such as chargeback fees and increased operational expenses, along with the risk of account suspension by payment processors.

‍

Why Do High-Risk Orders Occur?

High-risk orders typically stem from:

• Stolen Credit Card Details: Fraudsters use compromised card information to make unauthorized purchases.
• Friendly Fraud: Legitimate customers dispute transactions, claiming the product wasn't delivered, wasn't as described, or that they didn’t authorize the purchase.
• Suspicious Purchasing Behavior: Unusual activity, such as large first-time orders or multiple payment attempts, can signal potential fraud.

These risks are amplified in industries like electronics, luxury goods, and digital products, where high-value items are prime targets for fraudsters.

‍

How to Detect High-Risk Orders on Shopify

Shopify offers built-in fraud analysis tools to help merchants identify high-risk transactions. When an order is flagged as high risk, merchants should take steps to verify its legitimacy before fulfilling it. 

Here are some common red flags:

• Billing vs. Shipping Address Mismatch: If the billing and shipping addresses differ, it may indicate a fraudulent transaction.
• Frequent Order Changes: Multiple changes to shipping details post-purchase can be a sign of fraud.
• Large First-Time Orders: Fraudsters often place large orders with stolen cards to maximize their gains.
• Multiple Failed Payment Attempts: Repeated attempts with different cards may indicate stolen card testing.

‍

How High-Risk Orders Can Lead to Payment Holds

High-risk orders don’t just increase the risk of chargebacks—they can also result in payment holds by payment processors. Payment holds occur when platforms like Shopify Payments, PayPal, or Stripe temporarily freeze funds to mitigate risk, often due to suspicious transaction activity.

Here’s how high-risk orders contribute to payment holds:

• Fraudulent Transactions: A pattern of high-risk orders may signal potential fraud, prompting payment processors to hold funds for investigation.
• High Chargeback Ratios: Excessive chargebacks triggered by high-risk orders can label your business as risky, leading to payout delays or account restrictions.
• Unverified Transactions: If you fail to verify the legitimacy of high-risk orders, payment processors may freeze your account as a precautionary measure.

‍

‍

How to Handle High-Risk Orders on Shopify

Managing high-risk orders requires a proactive and strategic approach. Here's how merchants can minimize risks:

1. Perform Due Diligence

• Verify Customer Identity: Request government-issued ID, a credit card photo (showing only the last four digits), or proof of purchase.
• Contact the Customer: Call the phone number provided to confirm order details. Genuine customers will typically cooperate.
• Google the Email Address: Check if the email address is associated with previous fraud attempts.

2. Leverage Fraud Prevention Tools

Shopify’s fraud analysis tools provide insights into each order's risk level, but merchants can enhance their defenses with third-party apps like Disputifier. Disputifier uses AI to monitor transactions, send real-time alerts for high-risk orders, and provide actionable recommendations to avoid fraud and chargebacks.

3. Set Order Limits

Establish thresholds for maximum order values or quantities. This can deter fraudsters from targeting your store for bulk purchases.

4. Use Secure Payment Gateways

Platforms like PayPal, Stripe, and Shopify Payments offer robust fraud detection features to minimize risk.

5. Automate Chargeback Management

Dealing with chargebacks manually can be time-consuming and inefficient. With Disputifier, merchants can automate dispute management, ensuring timely responses and increasing the likelihood of winning chargeback disputes.

‍

The Role of Disputifier in Preventing High-Risk Orders

Disputifier is a game-changing solution for Shopify merchants looking to safeguard their business from high-risk transactions. 

By integrating Disputifier into your store, you can:

• Receive Real-Time Alerts: Get notified of suspicious activity immediately.
• Prevent Chargebacks: Issue refunds proactively or gather evidence to contest disputes.
• Streamline Dispute Management: Automate responses, saving time and improving win rates.

With its AI-driven fraud detection and comprehensive analytics, Disputifier empowers merchants to protect their revenue and focus on growing their business.

‍

Conclusion

High-risk orders are a persistent challenge for Shopify merchants, but they can be managed effectively with the right tools and strategies. By understanding what constitutes a high-risk order, utilizing Shopify’s fraud detection features, and leveraging advanced solutions like Disputifier, you can minimize fraud, reduce chargebacks, and ensure your business thrives. Protect your store today and keep your focus where it belongs—on delivering exceptional customer experiences.