When it comes to disputes, timing is everything. Many ecommerce merchants lose chargebacks not because of weak evidence—but because they miss critical response windows. Understanding the difference between pre-arbitration deadlines and chargeback time limits is key to protecting your revenue, maintaining compliance, and avoiding penalties from payment processors.

Let’s break down what these terms mean, why they matter, and how automation platforms like Disputifier can help you stay ahead of every dispute deadline effortlessly.

What is pre-arbitration in chargebacks?

Pre-arbitration—sometimes called a second chargeback—occurs when a dispute continues after the merchant’s initial response has been reviewed by the card issuer. It happens when:

• The issuer disagrees with the merchant’s evidence
• The cardholder provides new information
• The merchant’s response missed the original chargeback time limit

At this stage, the case reopens for further review. Visa and Mastercard both have specific pre-arbitration deadlines that vary depending on region, transaction type, and acquirer response times. Missing these windows usually means an automatic loss.

For a deeper understanding of pre-arbitration mechanics, review our guide on what pre-arbitration means and how it impacts chargebacks.

Chargeback time limits explained

Chargeback time limits are the initial deadlines that determine how long a cardholder or merchant has to file, respond to, or challenge a dispute.

For most Visa transactions, cardholders have up to 540 days from the original transaction date to dispute a charge. Merchants typically have 30 days or less to respond, depending on the issuing bank’s timeline.

You can learn more about the full Visa schedule in our post on Visa chargeback time limits and the 540-day rule.

Failing to respond within these timeframes can lead to an irreversible loss, even if your evidence is flawless.

Pre-arbitration deadlines vs. chargeback deadlines

While chargeback and pre-arbitration deadlines are related, they serve different purposes:

StagePurposeTypical DeadlineWho ActsChargebackMerchant disputes or responds to the first chargeback20–30 daysMerchantPre-arbitrationIssuer challenges the merchant’s first response10–20 daysMerchant or acquirer

Both timeframes operate within the broader 540-day Visa dispute cycle. Missing either one can result in automatic chargeback acceptance.

Automation tools like Disputifier track these layers in real time, ensuring you never miss critical deadlines that could cost your business thousands.

Why pre-arbitration matters for ecommerce merchants

Many merchants underestimate pre-arbitration because it seems like a rare escalation. In reality, it’s becoming more common as cardholders grow aware of dispute rights and fraud detection systems become stricter.

Failing to respond to pre-arbitration:

• Impacts chargeback ratios—every unresolved pre-arb becomes a recorded loss
• Damages merchant trust—processors view ignored pre-arbs as poor risk management
• Triggers fund holds—repeated inaction can cause acquirers to place reserves on your account
• Reduces win rates—your dispute success metrics drop across card networks

Merchants should treat pre-arbitration with the same urgency as an original chargeback—and ideally automate it to prevent costly oversight.

What happens if you miss a pre-arbitration deadline

If a merchant or acquirer fails to respond within the pre-arbitration period, the dispute typically escalates to arbitration, the final phase where Visa or Mastercard reviews the evidence and makes a binding decision.

Arbitration is expensive. Card networks charge non-reversible fees—often several hundred dollars per case. Beyond cost, arbitration outcomes are final, meaning merchants cannot contest them further.

This is why staying on top of pre-arbitration deadlines is vital. A missed date could mean losing both the dispute and additional network fees.

For more context, check our article on what happens if a merchant does not respond to a chargeback.

‍

‍

How Disputifier keeps merchants compliant

Tracking multiple dispute stages manually is unsustainable for growing ecommerce brands. Disputifier automates this process with precision.

Here’s how it helps:

• Automatic deadline tracking: Monitors every active dispute and pre-arbitration case in real time
• AI-powered response builder: Crafts strong, compliant evidence packets using transaction and communication data
• Pre-arb escalation alerts: Notifies your team instantly when a case moves into pre-arbitration
• End-to-end automation: Handles evidence submission, deadline compliance, and analytics in one place
• Integration with Visa RDR and real-time alerts: Resolves low-risk disputes automatically before they reach pre-arb

With Disputifier, merchants never have to guess which deadline applies or whether a dispute has advanced phases. Everything happens seamlessly through automation.

You can also strengthen your fraud prevention system with tools like Disputifier’s free BIN checker, which validates card data before transactions occur—reducing risk long before disputes arise.

Connecting pre-arbitration to your chargeback strategy

Pre-arbitration doesn’t exist in isolation. It’s one piece of the larger dispute lifecycle. To manage it effectively, ecommerce brands need an integrated system that covers:

• Chargeback time limits: Know every card network’s response schedule
• Pre-arb monitoring: Track escalations automatically
• Dispute evidence collection: Maintain organized proof for fast responses
• RDR and alert automation: Resolve early-stage disputes proactively
• Analytics and reporting: Identify root causes to reduce future disputes

Disputifier brings all these elements together under one dashboard—giving merchants full visibility into their dispute ecosystem.

FAQ: Pre-arbitration and time limits

What is pre-arbitration?
Pre-arbitration is the second stage of a dispute when the card issuer challenges the merchant’s original chargeback response.

How long do I have to respond to a pre-arbitration?
Typically 10–20 days, depending on the card network and acquirer.

Can pre-arbitration be avoided?
Yes. With automation tools like Disputifier and proactive refund handling through Visa RDR, you can prevent most pre-arb cases.

What happens if I ignore a pre-arbitration?
The dispute automatically escalates to arbitration, resulting in irreversible losses and additional fees.

How can Disputifier help?
Disputifier automates dispute tracking, submission, and compliance—ensuring you meet every deadline and avoid missed pre-arbitrations.

‍

‍

Stay ahead of deadlines with Disputifier

Every missed deadline is lost revenue. Between chargeback time limits, pre-arbitration responses, and Visa’s complex 540-day rule, manual tracking just isn’t sustainable.

Disputifier gives ecommerce merchants the tools to automate dispute management, reduce losses, and stay compliant—all from one intuitive dashboard.

Prevent pre-arbitration losses before they happen. Try Disputifier today and automate your chargeback protection.

‍